Refrigerator Buying Guide - Before you Buy Read This

Here's a detailed buying guide for refrigerators, including pros and cons for each type, as well as photos.

Refrigerator Buying Guide

Choosing the right refrigerator is a significant decision for any household. It's not just about keeping food cold; it's about efficiency, organization, and how well it integrates into your kitchen and lifestyle. This guide will help you navigate the various types of refrigerators, their advantages and disadvantages, and key features to consider.

Types of Refrigerators

1. Top-Freezer Refrigerators

These are the most traditional and often the most budget-friendly option, with the freezer compartment located above the fresh food section.

Pros:

  • Affordability: Generally the least expensive option to purchase.

  • Energy Efficient: Often more energy-efficient than larger, more feature-rich models due to the simpler design.

  • Spacious Fresh Food Section: The main compartment is at eye level, making it easy to access frequently used items without bending.

Cons:

  • Bending for Freezer: Requires bending down to access frozen items, which can be inconvenient for some.

  • Limited Capacity: May not offer enough space for larger families or bulk shoppers compared to other types.

  • Basic Features: Typically come with fewer advanced features or aesthetic options.

2. Bottom-Freezer Refrigerators

As the name suggests, the freezer is located at the bottom, often as a pull-out drawer, with the fresh food section on top.

Pros:

  • Eye-Level Fresh Food: The most frequently accessed items (refrigerated goods) are at a convenient height, minimizing bending.

  • Spacious Freezer: The drawer design can offer ample space for frozen goods, often with deep bins.

  • Better Organization (for some): Some models offer tiered drawers within the freezer for better organization of different frozen items.

Cons:

  • Higher Cost: Generally more expensive than top-freezer models.

  • Limited Freezer Organization (for others): Can be harder to organize and find items in a deep freezer drawer compared to shelves in a top or side-by-side freezer.

  • Bending for Freezer: Still requires bending to access the freezer, though less frequently than a top-freezer.

3. Side-by-Side Refrigerators

These refrigerators have two vertical doors, with the freezer on one side and the refrigerator on the other.

Pros:

  • Narrow Doors: Ideal for kitchens with limited space, as the doors require less clearance to open compared to single-door models.

  • Easy Access to Both Sections: Both fresh and frozen foods are accessible from top to bottom, reducing the need to bend.

  • Ice and Water Dispenser: Many models come with external ice and water dispensers, a popular convenience feature.

Cons:

  • Narrow Shelves: The narrow compartments can make it difficult to store wide items like pizza boxes, large platters, or oversized containers.

  • Limited Freezer Space: The freezer side may have less usable space for bulky items compared to a bottom-freezer drawer.

  • Less Energy Efficient: Can be less energy-efficient due to the vertical design and more frequent opening of two separate compartments.

4. French Door Refrigerators

These combine elements of side-by-side and bottom-freezer models, featuring two narrow doors for the fresh food section and a pull-out freezer drawer below.

Pros:

  • Spacious Fresh Food Compartment: Wide shelves allow for easy storage of large items like trays, platters, and pizza boxes.

  • Eye-Level Fresh Food: Convenient access to refrigerated items without bending.

  • Stylish Design: Often considered a premium and aesthetically pleasing option that enhances kitchen decor.

  • Energy Efficient: The narrow top doors help reduce cold air loss when only one side is opened.

Cons:

  • Higher Price Point: Typically the most expensive refrigerator type.

  • Freezer Organization: Similar to bottom-freezer models, the freezer drawer can be less organized for some users compared to shelves.

  • Requires More Space: The wide combined width of the top doors can still require ample clearance to open fully.

5. Counter-Depth Refrigerators

These refrigerators are designed to sit flush with your kitchen countertops, offering a more built-in and seamless look. They come in various configurations (French door, side-by-side, etc.).

Pros:

  • Sleek, Built-in Look: Creates a streamlined and custom appearance in your kitchen.

  • More Aisle Space: Doesn't protrude as much as standard-depth models, freeing up kitchen walkway space.

  • Variety of Styles: Available in most common refrigerator configurations, offering design flexibility.

Cons:

  • Reduced Capacity: Due to their shallower depth, they often have less interior storage space than standard-depth models of similar width.

  • Higher Cost: Generally more expensive than standard-depth refrigerators due to specialized design.

6. Built-in Refrigerators

These are high-end appliances that are integrated directly into your kitchen cabinetry, offering the most seamless and custom look. They are often wider and taller than standard models to compensate for their shallow depth.

Pros:

  • Fully Integrated Look: Provides a truly custom, high-end kitchen aesthetic, disappearing into the cabinetry.

  • Panel-Ready Options: Can be fitted with custom panels to perfectly match your existing kitchen cabinetry.

  • Enhanced Kitchen Flow: Maximizes floor space and creates a clean, uninterrupted line in your kitchen design.

Cons:

  • Very Expensive: Significantly more costly than other refrigerator types, including counter-depth models.

  • Professional Installation: Requires specialized installation by professionals to ensure proper integration.

  • Fixed Location: More permanent installation, making it difficult to move or replace without significant kitchen alterations.

7. Mini Refrigerators (Compact or Undercounter Refrigerators)

These small, portable refrigerators are ideal for dorm rooms, offices, bedrooms, or as secondary storage for beverages.

Pros:

  • Space-Saving: Perfect for very small spaces where a full-sized refrigerator isn't feasible.

  • Portability: Easy to move and relocate as needed.

  • Affordable: Generally the least expensive option to purchase.

Cons:

  • Very Limited Capacity: Not suitable for storing large amounts of food or for primary household use.

  • Basic Features: Few, if any, advanced features like ice makers or specialized compartments.

  • Less Energy Efficient (per cubic foot): While they use less overall energy, their energy consumption per cubic foot can be higher than full-sized models.

8. Wine Refrigerators (Wine Coolers)

Designed specifically for storing wine at optimal temperatures and humidity levels, protecting it from light and vibrations.

Pros:

  • Optimal Wine Storage: Maintains consistent temperature and humidity to preserve wine quality and flavor.

  • UV Protection: Often have UV-resistant glass doors to protect wine from damaging light exposure.

  • Dual-Zone Cooling: Many models offer separate temperature zones for storing red and white wines at their ideal temperatures simultaneously.

Cons:

  • Single Purpose: Only suitable for wine storage; not designed for general food refrigeration.

  • Can Be Expensive: Especially for larger, multi-zone models with advanced features.

  • Limited Capacity: Designed for bottles, not varied food items, limiting their versatility.

What Size of Refrigerator Do I Need?

Capacity: Measured in cubic feet, this indicates how much food the refrigerator can hold. Consider your household size, shopping habits, and how often you entertain.

1-2 people: 4 - 13 cu. ft.
3-4 people: 14 - 24 cu. ft.
5+ people: 25+ cu. ft.

  • Shopping Habits: If you buy groceries in bulk or shop infrequently, you'll need more capacity. If you shop daily or every few days for fresh items, you might need less.

  • Cooking Habits: If you cook frequently and store a lot of leftovers, or prepare large meals for entertaining, you'll benefit from more space.

  • Lifestyle: Do you host parties often? Do you keep a lot of beverages or specialized food items? These factors can increase your need for space.

  • Additional Freezers: If you have a separate chest or upright freezer, you can often opt for a smaller refrigerator, as your bulk frozen goods will be stored elsewhere.

Key Features to Consider When Buying:

  • Energy Efficiency: Look for ENERGY STAR certified models to ensure lower operating costs and a reduced environmental footprint. This can lead to significant savings on electricity bills over the appliance's lifespan.
  • Ice and Water Dispensers: A popular convenience feature. Consider whether you prefer internal or external dispensers, and remember they can take up valuable freezer space. External dispensers require a water line connection.

  • Adjustable Shelving and Door Bins: Provides flexibility for organizing different-sized items and adapting to your changing storage needs. Spill-proof shelves are a bonus.

  • Humidity-Controlled Crispers: Dedicated drawers with adjustable humidity levels help keep fruits and vegetables fresh longer by maintaining optimal moisture.

  • Smart Features: Wi-Fi connectivity, touchscreens, internal cameras (to see inside from your phone), and smart home integration for remote control, diagnostics, and inventory management.

  • Finish: Common finishes include stainless steel (classic, but prone to fingerprints), black, white, and panel-ready options. Consider smudge-proof or fingerprint-resistant stainless steel for easier maintenance.

  • Noise Level: Important for open-concept living spaces or kitchens close to bedrooms. Check decibel ratings or user reviews if noise is a concern.

  • Lighting: LED lighting is energy-efficient, long-lasting, and illuminates the interior well, making it easier to find items.

  • Specialty Drawers/Compartments: Look for features like deli drawers, temperature-controlled drawers (which can often be converted between fresh food and freezer temperatures), or specialized compartments for specific food types.

  • Door Alarms: Alerts you if the refrigerator door is left ajar, preventing food spoilage and energy waste.

Make Sure it Fits:

Carefully Measure
Measure the height, width, and depth of the space where the refrigerator will be placed to ensure a proper fit. Remember to account for door swing and ventilation space. 

By carefully considering these factors and understanding the pros and cons of each refrigerator type, you can choose a refrigerator that perfectly suits your needs, budget, and kitchen aesthetic, ensuring years of reliable food preservation.